Introduction

If your clinic bills a profession the Professional Services Guideline never mentions, insurers will often tell you the rate is $58.19 per hour. The line is real. The Guideline lists one rate under a heading called "Unregulated Providers," and $58.19 is it.

What insurers leave out is the sentence that follows in the same document. Services from professions not listed in the Guideline are not covered by the Guideline at all. The amount payable is determined by the parties involved. That gap, between "listed at $58.19" and "not covered at all," is where Ontario clinics win and lose rate disputes at the Licence Appeal Tribunal.

If you have ever accepted a rate reduction because "the Guideline says so," check first whether your provider is in the Guideline. The Tribunal's own billing decisions show how far a clinic can push a rate above the Guideline when the provider does not belong to the list.

The Guideline Covers a Short List

Superintendent's Guideline No. 03/14 sets maximum hourly rates for two groups.

The regulated professions, with catastrophic-impairment tiers in brackets:

| Profession | Maximum hourly rate | |---|---| | Chiropractor | $112.81 ($135.36 on catastrophic files) | | Psychologist or psychological associate | $149.61 ($179.29) | | Occupational therapist, physiotherapist, podiatrist | $99.75 ($119.92) | | Speech language pathologist | $112.22 ($134.17) | | RN, RPN, or nurse practitioner | $91.43 ($109.24) | | Massage therapist, kinesiologist | $58.19 ($89.07) |

Then a second heading titled "Unregulated Providers," listing five categories at $58.19 per hour, or $89.07 on catastrophic files:

  • Case managers
  • Family counsellors
  • Psychometrists
  • Rehabilitation counsellors
  • Vocational counsellors

If your provider is on either list, the listed figure is the ceiling, and the ceiling is firm. The first mistake clinics make is assuming the reverse: that being absent from the list means the $58.19 line applies by default. It does not.

Not Listed Means Negotiated, Not Free

The Guideline states it directly: services provided by unregulated providers and other occupations not listed are not covered by the Guideline, and the amounts payable are to be determined by the parties involved.

That covers a lot of Ontario clinics. Social workers. Registered psychotherapists. Osteopaths. Personal support workers. Driving instructors. Acupuncturists. Behaviour analysts. Athletic therapists. None of them appear anywhere in the appendix.

What follows is equally important. When the parties cannot agree, the Tribunal decides the rate on evidence. The onus sits with the claimant to show the proposed rate fits the provider's education, training, and experience. The insurer's opening position will almost always be $58.19. The Tribunal's finishing position depends almost entirely on what you file.

Rates the Tribunal Has Actually Awarded

The decisions below are all from ON LAT files where the provider was not in the Guideline. The numbers are the rates the Tribunal accepted.

| Provider type | Rate on record | Decision | |---|---|---| | Social worker and psychotherapist, treatment | $139 per hour, over the insurer's $100 | 2026 CanLII 15094 | | Registered psychotherapist, CV and supervision filed | $149.61 per hour | 2026 CanLII 59500; 2026 CanLII 53781 | | Social worker, assessment | $135 per hour | 2020 CanLII 126933 | | Driving instructor | $135 per hour | 2026 CanLII 100091 | | Social worker, no pre-service negotiation | $140 sought, $100 stood | 2026 CanLII 10329 | | Registered psychotherapist, no evidence filed | $99.75 "fair compromise" | 2026 CanLII 62976; 2026 CanLII 83311 | | Osteopath | $128.32 sought, $80 awarded | 2026 CanLII 34323 | | PSW, attendant care | $25 to $26 per hour | 2020 CanLII 126933 |

Three patterns jump out. First, the spread is wide: $25 to $149.61 for unlisted providers, and the difference is documentation, not profession. Second, the floor is rarely where the Tribunal lands. Insurers open at $58.19 and often end somewhere above it. Third, every figure above the floor came with filed evidence behind it.

The osteopath decision is the cleanest example of the whole system at work. The plan proposed $128.32 per hour. The insurer paid $58.19, arguing the unregulated line applied. The Tribunal rejected the cap and awarded $80, following a 2023 decision that cited the National Academy of Osteopathy's recommended rate. The market data did the work. Our full breakdown of that decision explains how the osteopath defended the rate and what winning exhibits look like.

Why the Same Profession Wins at $149.61 and Loses at $99.75

Registered psychotherapists are regulated by the College of Registered Psychotherapists of Ontario, but the Guideline has no line for them. That makes every RP file a rate dispute waiting to happen, and 2026 produced a clean split.

In two decisions against Aviva and Intact (2026 CanLII 53781 and 2026 CanLII 59500), psychotherapists were awarded the full psychologist rate of $149.61. Both files carried the same evidence: a CV, CRPO registration details, structured treatment under psychologist supervision, and in one case a section 10 special award against the insurer for misapplying the Guideline caps.

In two other 2026 decisions (2026 CanLII 62976 and 2026 CanLII 83311), the same profession settled at $99.75, an insurer "fair compromise" between the $58.19 unregulated line and the psychologist rate. No CV, no credential evidence, no complexity rationale. The Tribunal's phrasing has become the rule: title alone does not decide the rate. Evidence does.

The driving-instructor decision (2026 CanLII 100091) shows what happens when the insurer gets sloppy with the argument. Unifund's position was that driving instructors are "analogous to rehabilitation counsellors," so the Guideline's $58.19 applied. The Tribunal called the submission contradictory: the insurer could not argue the Guideline did not apply to the provider and then apply the Guideline rate in the same breath. These billing mechanics are the same ones covered in our 2026 HCAI invoicing decision roundup.

Build the File Before the Denial

The winning evidence set is the same across every profession. Compile it now, while no dispute is pending.

Market rate data for your discipline. Association surveys and fee guides carry the most weight. The Ontario Association of Social Workers publishes a private practice fee survey, and its motor vehicle sector rates of $130 to $150 per hour were accepted in a 2020 decision. The National Academy of Osteopathy publishes a recommended rate of $80 per hour, with a stated market range of $80 to $140. The BC Association of Clinical Counsellors publishes a 2026 fee guide with tiered rates by experience. The Alberta Athletic Therapists Association publishes field-work and assessment rates. Where no association guide exists, Government of Canada Job Bank wage data is a defensible substitute.

A CV and supervision structure. Education, certifications, years in practice, and the name of the supervising psychologist if one exists. This is the difference between the $149.61 files and the $99.75 files.

A case complexity note. One paragraph on why this patient's file requires the rate you propose. Multiple comorbidities, catastrophic designation, or a specialized modality all count.

A written rate agreement before service. In the decision where a social worker sought $140 and the insurer's $100 stood (2026 CanLII 10329), the Tribunal noted the provider had never contacted the insurer to agree on a rate before treating. A one-page rate letter before the first session is the cheapest protection available.

The PSW decisions are the same lesson from the other direction. A personal support worker's $25 to $26 hourly rate survived because the Form 1 figures the insurer tried to apply are calculation tools, not billing caps. The full explanation is in our post on why Form 1 hourly rates are not billing caps.

Conclusion

The $58.19 line is a starting position, not a finding. If your provider is genuinely listed in the Guideline, the table decides and there is little room to argue. If your provider is not listed, the rate is negotiable, and the Tribunal has shown it will accept $80, $135, $139, and $149.61 on the right evidence. Build the file before the denial arrives: market data, CV, complexity note, and a rate agreement signed before treatment starts.

List your clinic on CACF to put your practice in front of MVA patients across Ontario while your team focuses on the billing side.